The Full Wiki

More info on John Locke/Theories

John Locke/Theories: Misc

Advertisements
  

Lostpedia

Up to date as of February 07, 2010

From Lostpedia

Main Article Theories about
John Locke
Main Discussion
 Theories may be removed if ... 
  1. Stated as questions or possibilities (avoid question marks, "Maybe", "I think", etc).
  2. More appropriate for another article.
  3. Illogical or previously disproven.
  4. Proven by canon source, and moved to main article.
  5. Speculative and lacking any evidence to support arguments.
  6. Responding to another theory (use discussion page instead).
  • This does not include responses that can stand alone as its own theory.
  • Usage of an indented bullet does not imply the statement is a response.

See the Lostpedia theory policy for more details.

Contents

Healing

  • The driver of the car that hit Emily Locke was not Anthony Cooper but Richard Alpert himself. It was the first test conducted by Richard to see if Locke really was the chosen one.
  • The person driving the car that hit Emily was trying to make sure that Locke was never born.
  • This person could have been Ben. We know he's left the island multiple times and, for all we know, multiple periods in time. It would be an interesting twist. It could also have been Widmore as he was with Richard at the time Locke divulged his date and place of birth and could have used this information to locate John's mother and prevent her from ever giving birth to him. We know Widmore was also leaving the island multiple times and fathered Penelope during this time.
  • The Island has been protecting him all his life, from his early illnesses resulting from his premature birth ("Cabin Fever"), through his fall that should have killed him instead of "only" breaking his back ("The Man from Tallahassee"), to his recovery from his paralysis ("Pilot, Part 1") and being shot by Ben ("The Man Behind the Curtain"), who acknowledged that he was not thinking clearly when he shot Locke ("Cabin Fever").
  • The Island sent Abaddon to tell him to take a walkabout ("Cabin Fever"), positioning him for his delivery to the Island.
  • His legs stop working because the Island was preventing Locke from changing Boone's fate by making sure Locke could not climb up to the Beechcraft.
  • In "The Man from Tallahassee", we see Anthony Cooper push Locke out of a window. This should have killed him. In fact it did kill him and when Jacob touched him ("The Incident, Parts 1 & 2") he was brought back to life.
  • Jacob's nemesis can heal. He does this when Locke arrives on the island and again when he is shot (appearing as walt). He does this so he can ultimately die and he can take his form and kill Jacob.
  • Was it significant that not only was Locke resurrected when his body returned to the Island (Un-Locke, I guess), but also when Jacob touched him after he was pushed out of the window?

Locke's faith

  • The episode title "Lockdown" was named for the events occurring in the Hatch as well as "Locke" physically being brought "down". It was also foreshadowing regarding Locke's eventual fall from faith.
  • Faith played a bigger part in Locke's life while he lived on the marijuana commune in "Further Instructions", and suggests that he gradually lost his faith between that time and when he went to Australia.
  • John's tag line has always been, "Don't tell me what I can't do!" and his own bullheadedness leads him to deny his true destiny in favor of choosing his own way.

Jacob's enemy orchestrated the Time Flashes to manipulate John Locke

While at first the time periods visited seemed random, this is because we were learning about them primarily through the eyes of several different survivors. However, when focusing on John Locke's experiences only, and using current insight regarding the events of the Season 5 finale, a pattern begins to develop: John Locke's experiences during his time-traveling better serve to enhance his faith and his connection to the Island, and these experiences were a direct result of the manipulation of time-traveling by an outside force, conceivably and specifically, Jacob's enemy. Let's look at John Locke's final moments on the Island:

  • "Because You Left"
    • The Beechcraft First time jump; 1990's-ish. A crucial moment in John Locke's history with the island was the discovery of this airplane and the events that transpired. Look it up. Huge impact on John to experience this crash firsthand. This would likely influence his faith that the Island is guiding him somehow. Then he is shot in the leg and left for dead. Until...
      • Meeting with Richard. And guess who else? Jacob's enemy in John's body, and Ben listening in the distance. Jacob's enemy manipulated Richard to go over there. The words that Richard used to persuade John were the words of Jacob's enemy. He was manipulating all of them. John's mission is to leave the island, retrieve the Oceanic 6 and Ben then bring them to the island for some unknown purpose. This is also where we learn that John might have to die to accomplish this. So the flaw in logic is that the man impersonating John Locke after the return to the Island on Ajira 316 would have to know that John would die, and that the success of this plan would somehow lead to the events of "The Incident" for all parties involved. He would have to know the future; however, conceivably an enemy that had the ability to time-travel might know a thing or two about the future or the past.
  • "The Lie" and "Jughead"
    • The Flaming Arrows. During "The Lie" the survivors, not including John Locke, are attacked in their camp by a mysterious group or archers. After they escape they reunite with John, after he saves them from a group of people in U.S. Army fatigues. We learn in "Jughead" that these individuals were a group of people living on the island including Charles Widmore, Eloise Hawking, and...
      • Meeting with Richard, part 2. Part 1, technically. John makes his way into camp and meets with a version of Richard who is meeting John Locke for the first time. We know that John has a history with Richard. We know that Richard visited him in the hospital the day he is born, and that it was this future/past John that suggested he do that. Richard visited him as a boy, and was always telling John how special he was on the Island. Richard has a ton of faith in John. I think that this is the direct result of this experience. My belief is that the individual who is causing the time-travel is using this particular experience to manipulate Richard Alpert. He will listen to whatever John Locke says to him. John always speaks the truth and Richard recognizes this through all of his experiences with John over the years. So when Jacob's enemy comes to town in John's body, no matter how outrageous his demands, Richard will always obey.
  • "The Little Prince"
    • The Hatch, dude. The Hatch! After another time switch, John Locke and his people are taken to a night that happened a few months prior during Season 1 of the show. The events of that night at the hatch, where John sees the light from the underground facility, is one of the most important moments from John Locke's life: the moment his faith is solidified. John is calling out to God and God answers. Of course, it's not God. It's Desmond, but that doesn't matter. For the character of John Locke this seals the deal. He has total faith in the Island. Whatever happens John is going to go full force. Now he knows what he has to do. He is going to follow the path set out for him by Jacob's enemy without question. He thinks he is doing what is best for the Island, for his friends, and for himself and his devotion, but he's not. We know now that it was a manipulation, and I believe that John had to come to this decision by no other means. The enemy knew that John would have to experience a string of miracles, as he always does, before he would be convinced to do his bidding.
      • Back to the Future The survivors travel through time again, probably to now. It is a time after Ajira 316 has crashed on the island. They are persued by unknown assailants. They travel again out of harm's way. It's 1988 and Danielle and her team of scientists are living on the island. There are a series of jumps through time before John finally makes it to the Orchid station to complete his task of leaving the Island. These time jumps do appear to be more random in nature, but the rapid pace with which they occur begin to take their toll on the individuals involved. Charlotte, Miles, and Juliet could be dying. People everywhere are lost and alone. John is the only one who can stop the turmoil. While the current events of the time periods visited may not have any direct impact on the storyline of John Locke, the well-being of everyone on the Island is his priority as leader. They arrive at a modern version of the Orchid Station before quickly being transported to an earlier time where they find a well that John Locke enters. While John is going down the well the group is taken to a time before a well even existed. The result of this is John ending up at the bottom of the well with a broken leg. Very similar to what happened during "Because You Left", John is injured (in the leg), and meets with an eerie individual who instructs him further on his path. This time it is Christian Shepard. We don't fully understand yet who Christian is working for, or the how or why. He has stated in the past to John that he represents Jacob and his desires. We don't know what's going on with that. But he has the information that John needs to return to the island after he has fulfilled his mission. He also tells him how to leave. John leaves with the assistance of a big wheel.
  • "The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham"
    • John travels to the modern day in our dimension to reunite the Oceanic 6 and return them to the Island. John is a failure in his mission and is filled with self-doubt. He discovers that perhaps Richard was right. We know what happens after that. John dies. This new guy takes over John's identity. For what greater purpose we cannot know, yet. Part of that plan involves manipulating Benjamin Linus to kill Jacob with some assistance from Richard Alpert, things that have been set in motion for some time, but at least begining with the time-traveling.

Relation to the Others

Advertisements

Leadership of The Others

  • Ben did not kill Locke when he had the chance in "Lockdown". This is because Ben wants Locke to lead the Others.
    • In "The Man from Tallahassee" Ben reveals a curiosity and fascination with Locke due to his miraculous healing. This is what saved him. Had it been another of the Survivors Ben would have killed them and escaped.
  • Ben's manipulation of Locke into believing that he failed to push the button indicated he wanted him to concentrate less on the then seemingly trivial tasks of the Swan.
  • John's leadership will be the end of the Others. He was supposed to be a scientist, (based on actions by Richard) and not the rough-and-tumble knife-wielding type (as Abaddon wanted).
  • John is only leader of the Others because Richard knew if he didn't become leader he would never go back in time and it would cause a time-paradox.
  • Locke makes his own destiny. The only thing that allows him to be leader of the others is that Alpert remembers him from their meeting in 1954 and therefore goes to his birth in 1956 and visits him all throughout his childhood. Alpert remembers Locke from their meeting in 1954 and thinks he is destined to become leader of the Others; however it is only because Locke is given leadership of the Others that he is back in 1954 in the first place. Nowhere in there is he given a mandate, which is why the island is going out of control. The Others, and therefore the Island, are missing a leader. When the Oceanic 6 left so did the true future leader of the Others, presumably Jack or Aaron, but it is unsure which one. That is why they all need to return.

Not the Leader of the Others or the Survivors

  • Although John Locke has a special connection to the island, he is not the rightful leader. He is not a man of science (like Richard, Ben, Jack etc.) and has yet to speak with Jacob (despite claiming to). He told Richard he was their leader, but as we saw in Cabin Fever, Locke failed all of Richard's 'tests'. John's destiny is to help the island (or die trying) bring back its true leader: Jack Shephard
  • The whole reason that Locke is believed to be meant to lead the Others is because he told Richard that he was their leader in the future when they were in 1954.
  • Jack is supposed to be the leader and Locke will become Jack's leader. Jack and Locke will replace Ben and Richard.

Reincarnation

  • Locke is the reincarnation of Magnus Hanso. In the episode Cabin Fever, Richard Alpert asks John to identify items that already belong to him. This is similar to a process that is used to determine who has been reincarnated as the new Dalai Lama. He chose a compass and a vial of sand. He recognized the Book of Laws but took the knife because that is what he wanted. This disappointed Alpert who knew that he was lying. Damon and Carlton said that they researched the search for Dalai Lamas in the Official Lost Podcast/May 8, 2008.
    • It might be possible, though, that the knife did belong to John and that Alpert was more distressed by that thought than disappointed in John--Perhaps the knife belongs tot he Man in Black and Locke has somehow been intimately connected with him since brith--he would, then, still be special, but maybe not so much in a good way.
  • Young Locke does not choose correctly. These are not items from the older Locke's future but rather the items that were owned by the person who Locke is supposed to be a reincarnation of. The leader of the island is not supposed to be a hunter but a man of laws. We see through Locke's childhood and teenage years that he constantly denies his true nature as a man of science.
  • Orignally after the tests Locke was thought not to be a reincarnation but eventually proves he is . After Locke, in his younger years, Ben was thought to be the reincarnation of Magnus Hanso.
  • The importance of taking children is because the others, mainly Richard, want to test to see if it's Magnus Hanso reincarnated but ultimately it turns out to be Locke even though he fails to complete the tests.

Interaction with the Monster

  • Locke's first encounter with "the Monster" was in the jungle while hunting for boar. When approached Locke faced up to the Monster and later told Jack, "I've looked into the eye of this Island..., and what I saw was beautiful." One might conclude that this was the first time Locke knew that the Island was where he belonged. That first encounter may not have been "The Monster" at all, but something entirely different. Or, if it was the same entity, it (from what has been described of it) took on entirely different characteristics from what we have seen and know of the Monster.
  • During that encounter Locke is converted by/to the island in some manner analogous to Rousseau's team("This Place Is Death").
  • Every other time we see The Monster (as itself, not other people) in the show, it's either killing people or scanning them and showing them their past. If this was the monster, and it was scanning John, he wouldn't say what he saw was beautiful, since his life was pretty much humiliating, and this would be the first time the monster showed up as a bright light entity, hinting at a possibility that it wasn't the monster that he saw.

Miscellaneous theories

  • Locke's ultimate aim is to learn more about the island, being the place that has healed him. He is simply using the Others as his means of gaining this information.
  • Locke will soon become the new leader of the Others only to either get them to co-exist with all the other Losties or to get their info on the island and then set them up to be captured. This won't happen until he becomes the leader so he can learn as much as he can.
  • Locke is partly responsible for the death of Charlie. When Charlie and John were searching for Eko after the discharge he told Charlie that "Bad things happen to people who hang around me." Boone hung around Locke and was even his apprentice for weeks before being killed after the Beachcraft fell from the cliff. Eko hung around Locke for a shorter amount of time, but was beaten to death by the Monster. Charlie hung around with Locke for a while also, before drowning in The Looking Glass.
  • Locke has prior military service. His interest in military strategy can be seen by his role-playing a colonel while playing Risk at the box company ("Walkabout"). Additionally, another hint surfaces in The Man from Tallahassee that he may be a Vietnam veteran: the government worker tells him, "It's relevant, Mr. Locke, because if the government's going to continue paying your disability insurance, I have to figure out whether or not your condition has improved," which could refer to a veteran's benefit. Ben doesn't contradict Locke when he says, "For all you know I was a commander in the navy." Despite Ben's intention to show Locke that he knows about Locke's life, he doesn't contradict or counter this statement in any way, instead looking a little confused. Also, in Man from Tallahassee, while he is watching TV in his apartment, what looks to be a framed collection of military combat patches is displayed behind him, above the couch.
    • In ("Walkabout"), in response to John's friend calling him Colonel, John's boss Randy says, "...Tell me more about being a leader, Locke. While you're at it, tell me about this Col. thing. I cruised your file in human resources, you've never been in any of the armed forces." That's pretty definitive proof that John never served in the military.
  • Richard's test (Cabin Fever") was to see which period of his life (if any) Locke was flashing back from (a-la Desmond) when Richard arrived. Since Locke wasn't flashing back (as far as we know) his answer confused Richard, who was expecting the self-proclaimed leader of the Others (in 1954) to be someone with Desmond's abilities.
  • John Locke is a symbol for Christ. When Shepherd made the comment about knowing the meaning of sacrifice to John and then how John made his way with his battered body to the wheel, it was symbolic of Jesus' sacrifice and His journey to the cross. In the Bible the House of Jacob refers to the nation and people of Israel. It is prophesied in the Bible that the Israelites will return to their homeland (which is the House of Jacob) when Armegeddon takes place and Jesus returns. This is represented on Lost by what's going with the O6 trying to get back to the island, John Locke sacrificing his life and being restored. Also, John's father's real name was Anthony Cooper. Therefore, using the standard tradition of a child taking his father's surname, his name is "John Cooper" - JC: Jesus Christ. I believe this is an intentional easter egg on the part of the writers.
  • Never destined to be on 815 but was destined to be on the Island.

John Locke as the Savior of the Island

  • John is the true leader of the island and the Others have been waiting for him for a long time.
John has been subjected to a series of tests since he came to the island, to test whether he was truly ready to be the leader of the island.
1. He was tested to see if he could let go of his emotions about another person when necessary. This was in the form of Boone dying; and John passed it by accepting that it was necessary for Boone to die.
2. He was tested to see if he was willing to kill for the island. He failed the first time, when he could not bring himself to kill his father. This test,however, was contrived by Ben and not the true test. John passed the true test when he killed Naomi in cold blood to be able to protect the island.
3. He was tested to see if he would give up a life on the island he loved in order to protect it. He was not able to pass or fail this test, because Ben took his place not knowing that it was for Locke to do. If Locke had turned the wheel, knowing he could not return, he would not have been ejected from the island, and would have passed this test.
4. The final test was to see if John was willing to die for the island. Unfortunately the only way to ever truly prove that somebody is willing to die for something is for them to ACTUALLY die for it. Fortunately he was never intended to stay dead and, having now proven that he will do anything for the island, he will be resurrected upon his return to the island.
  • John is special because he can lead without being corrupted. Ben and Widmore have proven they cannot. The war Widmore spoke of is, of course, between Ben and Widmore, but ultimately neither will win. Only John will survive to lead the Others, the survivors of both the 815 and the 316, and any remaining people on the island. John will also prove to be the solution as to why reproduction is fatal on the island.
  • The answer to the question "What lies in the shadow of the statue" is "he who will save us all." Earlier in the series, John Locke uses similar words when he refuses to push the button. When Desmond says, "you've killed us all," John responds by saying, "No, I've saved us all." He's right. The detonation of Jughead transcends time and space. Jughead is what destroyed "the hatch" when Desmond turns the key. Juliet's detonation of Jughead "bleeds over" from the 1977 timeline to the 2004 timeline. This parallel destruction of the Swan station will "reboot" the series. The lostaways will arrive at LAX, only with their memories intact. They will then band together to use their knowledge of the Island to rescue it from Ben and Jacob's Nemesis.

Possible cultural references

Esau

In the Bible Esau is the twin brother of Jacob. Esau is a "hunter who prefers the outdoor life", while Jacob was "a gentle man who dwelled in tents". Locke hunts and, in "the Brig", Ben is seen living in a tent. Also Esau is the son of Isaac. In the Bible we have the Abraham/Isaac sacrifice tale; in "the Brig" Locke spares his father ("Isaac"?). It seems very much like a retelling of the Bible story in reverse.

Lugus

The highest deity in the Gaulic pantheon, Lugus was a nature god, a hunter and a craftsman. His name was Lugh to Irish Celts and might be connected to Loki, this time the Nordic trickster. Those two aspects cover Locke's ambiguous personality. Lugus' father Cian was able to change forms to appear as animals or other people, not unlike Locke's con-man father Anthony Cooper. Lughnasa (the feast of Lugus) is the Irish word for the month of August, as the god Lugus was associated with the harvest. Lugus was known for being multi-skilled rather than proficient in one area.

Josaiah

Josaiah was the King of Judah. According to the story told by Eko in What Kate Did, while Josiah was in power, the Temple was in ruin and people worshiped false gods. Josiah wished to rebuild the Temple with gold but was unable to. Instead they used the Book of Laws to rebuild. Locke was presented with the Book of Laws as a child and he didn't accept it as something which belonged to him. The Temple is a sanctuary for the Others. Locke will use the Book of Laws to correct the damage which Ben, the false god, has caused. This will allow him to rebuild the Temple and the community of the island.

The "Real" Locke will Return

  • When Ilana asks Richard what lies in the shadow of the statue, he replies (in Latin) with "he who will protect/save us all". The "will" implies that this refers to someone other than Jacob, a savior or leader who has yet to rise to prominence. Interestingly the only person currently "lying in the shadow of the statue" is the corpse of the real John Locke, perhaps implying that a true resurrection is in store and that Locke really is "special" and destined to save the island from "Jacob's Nemesis", or whichever force is revealed to be the true enemy.
    • Richard claims that Locke "never seemed special", but Jacob tells Hurley that he (Hurley) is blessed by his ability to communicate with spirits of the departed. The real John may save and protect everyone by appearing to Hurley in spirit and explaining to him how he, and the rest of the people Jacob has chosen, can stop Jacob's opponent and fix whatever negative effects Jacob's death will have on the island and its people. This would also recall Charlie's dialogue to Jack in Season 1 that "if there's one man I expect to absolutely save us all, it's John Locke".
  • The philosopher John Locke wrote about personal identity and consciousness, believing one being could serve as a host for two separate consciousnesses as long as past experiences and memories existed for each. This philosophy is related to the Christian idea of Resurrection and the question of a person's identity remaining the same after resurrection. In Locke's book, An Essay on Human Understanding, Locke poses that consciousness can be transferred from one being to another while preserving one's personal identity. It is possible that the physical body of John Locke is "dead" but that his identity, or consciousness, now exists in the new body of Jacob's nemesis. They are working together to eradicate Jacob's authoritarian control over the island.
    • Not to quibble, but those ideas are not at all related to the Christian idea of Resurrection. And it seems more likely that Un-Locke pilfered the real Locke's memories from the dead body, to give himself more credibility, than that John's consciousness somehow found itself inside of an entirely newly-created body that Un-Locke was inhabiting.
  • It is shown in the flashback that Jacob possibly saved Locke from death. I doubt Jacob would do that unless Locke still had a role to play at that point. I suppose it's possible that Locke's role was simply bringing the O6 back, but it's also possible that he still has another, much bigger purpose left to fulfill.
    • There also would be no need to bring Locke's body all the way to the statue if there were no more need for his body. Doing so may serve as a dramatic tool for telling the story (and it did) as a "big reveal," as well as showing proof that Locke is really dead, but why go through all the trouble of lugging his body clear across the island?
  • Many parallels have been made between Locke and the Christ story. He sacrificed himself to save his people, he was betrayed by a man he thought was a friend, and his death brought many people together and helped them believe in his message. The scene where Locke turned the wheel was reminiscent of Christ's journey to the cross, his initials would be JC if he had taken his father's name, a combination of his first name and flight 316 is a reference to a very famous Bible verse concerning Jesus, and his mother was talking about his immaculate conception all the way back in season 1. He is also missing a kidney, which would give him a scar in the same location as the wounds of Jesus (which Thomas had to see before he believed Jesus had returned.) Thomas is Jack, who doubted Locke's abilities for quite a long time but eventually ended up believing in him. This connection was pretty much cemented with Locke's placement in the very center of the table in the latest Last Supper-based s6 promo. It would not make much sense if Locke received all of these Christ allusions and then did not really come back to life, which leads me to believe that he will. It seems as though Ilana's people are attempting to bring him back, seeing as they carried his body across the island so that "he who will save us all" (emphasis on will, that means he still has work to do) really would "lie in the shadow of the statue."
    • The response to the "shadow of the statue" question still refers to Jacob, even though it is John's body which literally lies in the shadow. Jacob will come back from the dead in John's body, just as his nemesis used John to get to Jacob. It would make more sense that Ilana was trying to revive Jacob than John, and would explain the task that Jacob asked of Ilana when he visited her in the Russian hospital.
  • Sayid died but later came back to life. It is possible Locke's body went through a similar process that Sayid's did.

Waleesa says: I have also discovered/realised that the real Locke will still be resurrected even after the events of Season 6 episode: LA X. Reason? Go back to Season 5 and watch episode: The Life & Death of Jeremy Bentham. - where Locke goes to New York to see Walt and Walt says he's been having dreams about him. - that "Locke was in a suit on the island & there were people around him who wanted to hurt him." I think they wanted to hurt him because they thought he was Flocke/MIB/Nemesis. Real Locke will still be resurrected.

Locke always remained the "real " Locke

  • While the "Locke proxy" theories (a different entity took over Locke's body) do have some appeal, the actual phenomenon is explainable by "simple" time-travel. One can obviously go back in time and meet oneself in an earlier stage (Miles met himself as a baby). It would have been impossible to kill the baby - otherwise the grown up Miles never existed. If one traveled to the future one would also be able to visit his/her own corpse. This is exactly what is happening in season 5; before Locke dies, he travels to the future to get Jacob killed (and more deeds that will follow in season 6). It is no paradox at all that his corpse exists at the same time. Of course Locke will have to return at a later stage and - as an older man - get killed by Ben - in full knowledge that Jacob will be killed by him in the actual future (but his experienced past). The same happened to Jack's father Christian (his "coffin story" is a parallel to Locke's story). Many strange LOST events can be explained by ordinary time-travel done right.
    • It's possible. The whole assumption that "fake Locke" is MIB is based Jacob's remark that he found his loophole. However, Jacob may have told John Locke to find a loophole, just as he had told MIB to find a loophole in order to have someone kill Jacob (for some yet-to-be revealed reason). MIB, not a nemesis of Jacob, wasn't able to find loophole, but Locke did.

Locke and the Island

  • There has always been a disconnect between what "the Island" would want and what "Jacob" would want. We see that conflict in a variety of settings. Ben for a long time has been unable to distinguish between what the Island wants and what Jacob wants. When he says in "Cabin Fever" that he "used to have dreams" and the constant reminder that he has been following Jacob's orders that are written on a piece of paper (we have seen this before but most clearly stated in Incident Part 2). This shows that he has no idea what the difference is between Jacob and the Island. Locke, on the other hand, does know. He understands that Jacob has a level of power of manipulation of the Island's powers that are very powerful. In order to truly gain control of the Island you must win over the Island's trust and be able to manipulate the Island better than Jacob.
    • I would actually think one would want to be more in tune with what Jacob wants than what the Island wants. The reason for this is simple. It's always been suggested that the Others are in better communion with the Island than with anyone else, that they really are the "good guys" for some reason. While certain people, such as Ben and Widmore, have expressed things in terms of the Island's wishes, most of the Others, including Richard Alpert, seem more concerned with Jacob's wishes. If the Island's wishes and Jacob's wishes are separate (which there is not necessarily any evidence for), then I think the evidence points toward Jacob as being the one you want to listen to. Plus, Locke mostly refers to what the Island wants, himself, so I don't know if he has any more knowledge than anyone else about the truth.

Walt's dream

In "Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham" Walt tells Locke that "I've been having dreams about you. You were on the Island wearing a suit and there are people all around you. They wanted to hurt you, John." The scene that Walt describes refers to the moment when post-death Locke or "Jacob's Enemy" is first revealed and he is surrounded by the passengers of 316.

  • It perhaps foreshadows a moment after Richard and the Others discover he is not really Locke and attempt to kill him. Walt's dream was not about Locke, but Nemesis in the guise of Locke
  • except Locke was not wearing a suit at this time and makes the dream incorrect.
    • His corpse is wearing a suit in the coffin.
  • Walt's dream refers to events that will take place in Season 6. Locke is seen wearing a suit at the end of Season 5 when his body tumbles out of the metal crate.

Jacob's Enemy Playing Locke

  • Jacob's nemesis is the orchestrator of Locke's destiny. Every event (dreams, healing, the Monster, etc.) that caused Locke to believe he was special was caused by Jacob's nemesis and not Jacob. Nemesis did this in order to manipulate everyone (Richard, Jacob, Locke, etc.) into believing Locke as a leader and used that leadership as a way to kill Jacob. Nemesis was the one who convinced Locke to leave the island (via Christian) and the one to tell him he must die (via Richard), all in order to take his body. This was the "longest con" in history.
    • Tabula rasa is an idea developed by philosopher John Locke that says the mind is a blank slate and only develops when nurtured. The Monster (aka Esau) first meets Locke in Walkabout and spares his life because Locke was judged as as a man of faith, not free will (the opposite of Jacob's belief). This made him the perfect blank slate to be nurtured and thus conned.
      • This logic is entirely flawed. The idea that one can be categorized as "faith, not free will" shows a complete misunderstanding of not only these ideas but of these themes in the show. In actuality you are referring to two different dichotomies, not one. There is science vs. faith (in my mind more accurately expressed in the terms "skepticism vs. faith"), and then there is the linked, but completely different, fate vs. free will. To say one is "faith, not free will" is like saying that one likes the color blue, and not sweet-tasting. It doesn't make any sense, because it refers to two different categories. Furthermore, Locke has always been on the side of free will, rather than fate. Destiny and fate are not at all the same things. Destiny presupposes a planned end, an action or actions pre-appointed for a person to take, that the person was meant to take. That doesn't mean at all that a person has no choice in whether he takes these actions. To Locke, it has always been about choosing to take up your destiny. It's something that has to be accepted. Whereas with fate, you have no real choice. It will happen if you choose it, or if you choose against it, or if you take no action toward or against it at all. If Locke were really on the fate side, he wouldn't have ever spent so much energy trying to convince the other survivors of his views. So yes, Locke represents faith, but he also very much represents free will as well.
    • Jacob's nemisis inhabited Locke's body when the plane (Oceanic 815) crashed. That is why Locke was able to walk, recovered after being shot, and many other healings that took place for Locke. Also, he knew that island like no one else on the plane at the time of the crash. He spoke of destiny from Season One right after the crash. The real John Locke died in that plane crash and Jacob's enemy took over Locke and thus John Locke became the ultimate sacrifice.
    • Jacob's nemisis could not have inhabited Locke's body from the Oceanic 815 crash because you can see Locke is "different" after 316 crashes. He is a true leader and is comfortable in the leader position. He is not comfortable as a leader when the groups split between him and Jack in Season 4. The real John Locke was never special and was only made out to be.

Bible reference

  • flight number 316 + John Locke = John 3:16, the Bible: "For God so loved the world that He gave His one and only Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life." emphasis added
  • perhaps indicating how Richard never ages, he believes in Jacob. As Richard says "I'm this way because of Jacob".
  • Numerous times is referred to being "like Moses." Moses did not make to the promised land and so too was John Locke's journey ended early.

Locke's destiny as leader of the Others

  • Richard is the one who helps pick the Others' leader. During the time jumps seen in the first 6 episodes of Season 5 Locke tells Richard, in "Jughead", that he is their leader and giving him a compass sets Richard on a journey of verifying Locke's leadership. In "LaFleur", Sawyer explains to Richard who they (Losties/Kahana crew) are by reminding him of their 1954 encounter. Then in "The Incident, Parts 1 & 2", Jack tells Richard that he wouldn't give up on Locke. Richard takes all of this info and convinces Locke of his destiny to be the leader of the island. Unknowingly John is the maker of his own destiny.
  • Jacob's nemesis starts it all by healing Locke when he arrives on the island.
  • Locke represents Jacob (The Optimist). Jack represents Jacob's enemy (The Pessimist)

Locke Was Always "Flocke"

  • Okay, there are loads to contradict this 'theory'. You might even say it isn't a theory, simply something to raise awareness to. I was watching Season 1 yet again, but this time focusing on Locke and pretending he really was Flocke at that time, too.
  • Where to start? Well, there was nothing out of place until Locke encountered Smokey in Walkabout. I'm convinced he was Locke until that encounter. Suspicion arose when Jack was missing in 'White Rabbit'. Jack was chasing Christian/Smokey and therefore Christian/Smokey knew where Jack was. On the beach, people question Jack's whereabouts. Sayid and Kate consult Locke. Locke says "I'll go" followed by "Besides, I know where he is". Strange? Much like Flocke knew where Smokey was, at the Temple. Anyway, moments later, Jack's hanging for his life when Locke appears just in time to pull Jack up. If it's worth anything, Locke also begins telling Jack how special the Island is moments later.
    • "Besides I know where he is" is a misquote and the quote wasn't really referring to finding Jack at all. Kate and Sayid are talking to John about someone having stolen the water after Claire collapsed. Kate says she'll go look for water. Sayid tells Kate she can't go alone. John says "When the others find out the water is gone it's gonna get ugly. And when they find out that someone pinched it, it's gonna get uglier. I'll go. Camp needs you two here, especially with the doctor gone. And besides I know where to LOOK." John is going to look for water not for Jack. One can presume that he knows where to look for water because of the years of training he put in for his walkabout. He comes across Jack by coincidence. It might seem like a huge coincidence but if you'll notice there is a small riverbed below Jack at the bottom of the cliff indicating that there was fresh water nearby which John was out looking for. Also, in the next scene Charlie further reinforces that John went to go look for water when he tells Claire "...I wouldn't worry. Good old Mr. Locke has gone into the jungle to get some more water for you."
  • Another occasion, the one that stands out the most, was in the discovery of 'Adam & Eve'. You should watch the scene to gain a clearer understanding of what I'm getting at, though. Anyway, Jack mentions the corpses and to me, a very serious and concerned face falls on Locke. To add to this, he automatically assumes they were two men (Jacob & MIB). Strange? He also automatically asks who they were. If I recall, Locke and Jack stare at each other in a very 'knowing' manner. Or it assumed so to me. Also, whilst holding the stones, as soon as Jack sees Locke approach, he quickly pockets them.
    • Charlie says, "Are these the people that were here before us?" This is when Jack gives Locke the "look" you mentioned. Remember that only Kate, Shannon, Boone, Sayid, Charlie, Sawyer, and Jack know about the radio transmission from Danielle saying that everyone died. Charlie spills the beans and tries to cover it up. The concerned look on Jack's face is because he doesn't want Locke to find out they were hiding something from him. The stones do seem to be significant because there is one black and one white. However, Jack doesn't pocket them immediately, he holds them in his hand for a second, puts them back in the pouch (with John looking right at him), and then holds the pouch there for another few seconds.
  • Smokey is often, and rightfully so, regarded as a 'Judge, Jury & Executioner'. He gives people the chance to redeem themselves and perhaps reward them. In the same episode, 'House of the Rising Sun', Charlie escapes to use the drugs. Locke follows and tell Charlie he knew about them. Strange? More suspicious than that, he tells Charlie that the Island will reward Charlie if he gave Locke the drugs. After all, Charlie craved his guitar.
  • In 'The Moth', the second time Charlie asks for the drugs, Locke shows Charlie a Moth Cocoon. Is it strange how this gets Charlie to back down. And how it also turns out to be a Moth that shows Charlie a way out of the caves?
  • Now, before you go judging. I myself find this slightly hard to believe. After all, Smokey attacks Locke in the finale. He is clueless to the button and its purpose. To the Others. Perhaps in Locke's first encounter, Smokey possesses Locke? And something in the middle of the series brings Locke back? Prolly not. This 'theory' if you wish to call it that is written hear to just highlight a few things that struck me as strange during the rewatch and might need a bit of poking into if anything here might actually be true. Anyway, it's something to think about, at least.

Locke/Flocke

  • Flocke can not leave the island. Flocke knows Locke's final thoughts as he died. To mitigate these two facts, one must conclude that Locke was always Locke. Flocke integrated Locke's consciousness when his body was brought to the island on the plane. This explains why Nemesis/Smokey/Flocke was able to take the shape of Yemi, and Christian.

This article uses material from the "John Locke/Theories" article on the Lostpedia wiki at Wikia and is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike License.

Advertisements






Got something to say? Make a comment.
Your name
Your email address
Message