The Full Wiki

More info on Claire Littleton/Theories

Claire Littleton/Theories: Misc



Up to date as of February 07, 2010

From Lostpedia

Main Article Theories about
Claire Littleton
Main Discussion
 Theories may be removed if ... 
  1. Stated as questions or possibilities (avoid question marks, "Maybe", "I think", etc).
  2. More appropriate for another article.
  3. Illogical or previously disproven.
  4. Proven by canon source, and moved to main article.
  5. Speculative and lacking any evidence to support arguments.
  6. Responding to another theory (use discussion page instead).
  • This does not include responses that can stand alone as its own theory.
  • Usage of an indented bullet does not imply the statement is a response.

See the Lostpedia theory policy for more details.


Biblical Descent

Also see Aaron Littleton/Theories

  • In Charlie's dream that mirrors the The Baptism of Christ, Claire appears as the Mary figure. Claire represents Mary, therefore Aaron represents Jesus Christ and the savior of the Island.

Unseen Past

  • Claire took extreme offense in "Raised by Another" when referred as "crazy" by Charlie. She had a similar reaction to Hurley when someone referred to him as "crazy". As a teenager, Claire couldn't deal with the sudden impact of finally meeting her biological father, surviving a fatal accident and her Mother being in an induced coma of which Claire thought she was the cause. She was admitted to a psychiatric hospital and whilst there, met a man named Thomas. They were released from the hospital around the same time and continued their lives together. The reason Claire took such an interest in Thomas was because all he did during his time in the hospital was paint therefore Claire knew how important Thomas' painting was to him.

Fertility Experiments

  • The testing that Others where doing on her while in captivity were fertility experiments. They took blood samples from her and gave her vaccinations in The Staff.
  • She was meant, along with Aaron, to be a part of the Others' genetics/fertility-related experiments.
    • This has been proven to a degree, given that they were analyzing Claire to see if they could find a cure to their own fertility issues. And Aaron is probably the first child born on the island since Alex, and there is no indication whether fertility had become an issue when she was born or whether the Others were simply unable to capture and analyze Danielle before she gave birth.

Death theories


Is dead

  • Claire is dead (allowing for the idea she may be "dead" in the same sense that Christian Shepard is dead). She did not die at the barracks. Hurley, Sawyer, Locke et al have been interacting with and possibly touching her (definitely touching in Sawyer's case her) since the RPG round hit her house. She suffered a blow to head in the explosion and then was very disoriented. Sawyer commented and said "she got her bell rung but she'll be fine." After that, when asked how she was feeling, she said she had a headache but was fine. Victims that have had head injuries often feel fine but then later they have brain haemorrhage and it eventually kills them. It is a symptom of severe concussions.
    • Claire does die (technically) from belated brain haemorrhaging in Something Nice Back Home, but her body and soul are subsequently restored by the island similar Christian. At that point, Jacob sends Christian to escort Claire to The Temple (leaving Aaron behind in the jungle), where she later projects her image to Locke in the cabin and to Kate off of the island. This happens because the Island has decided that Claire "still has work to do" and is important to protecting the island.
  • Claire's last nurturing act as a mother is to feed (nurse?) Aaron, and lie down with him for the night. She dies, is absorbed by the Island and "awakes" to find Aaron apparently missing but actually in the arms of his grandfather, Christian. Together, they find a safe place to leave Aaron where Sawyer is sure to find him and leave for their ultimate meeting with Locke at Jacob's Cabin.
  • Miles' interest in Claire is based on the realization that she is about to die. He asks to carry Aaron because this is his first experience with pre-death and he does know what will happen when Claire crosses over(dies), and he doesn't want Aaron to be dropped and killed.
  • Claire is dead, having died in the barracks when the mercenaries blew up her house. Why the others could see her is unknown. Perhaps it was the islands will. This explains why Miles was so interested in her. Wondering why, since she was dead, everyone (including herself) acted as if she were alive. Knowing she was dead, Christian Shepard went to her. She wanted to take Aaron with her, but he explained that she could not and convinced Claire to leave Aaron where the others could find him.

Is not dead

  • Claire is not dead. The reason why Miles was acting strange was because he could sense Christian near her and wanted to carry Aaron as a precaution.
  • Claire is not dead. Locke is dead and now taken over by Jacob's nemesis. Claire was forced to give up Aaron, as Jacob's enemy needs him for something. She tells Kate (through her dream), "dont you dare bring him back." This was so Aaron can be protected off-island from Jacob's nemesis.
  • Claire is not dead. Jacob's nemesis posed as Christian to draw her into the cabin. As Jacob was located at the base of the statue, the cabin is most likely not Jacob's cabin at all, but rather the "prison" for Jacob's nemesis. Jacob's nemesis has her leave Aaron by the base of the tree knowing that whoever escapes the island (the Oceanic Six) would assume responsibility for Aaron and take him off the island. Jacob's nemesis appears as Claire off-island in a visit to Kate and urges her to keep Aaron away from the island simply because, as the show has repeatedly made clear, Aaron is special - Aaron alone has the power to bring upon the downfall of Jacob's nemesis, hence the complex chain of events coordinated by Jacob's nemesis to lead him off-island. Contrary to the theory above, this isn't about protecting Aaron from Jacob's nemesis, it's the opposite - this is about Jacob's nemesis protecting himself from Aaron. This might be incorrect, but the only times that "bodies" have appeared off-island (Christian visiting Michael on the freighter right before it explodes, Christian's visit to Jack after the smoke alarm goes off in the hospital, Ana Lucia pulling Hurley over, etc.) occur AFTER Claire is led to the cabin and breaks the circle of ash, thus freeing Jacob's nemesis to travel off the island in the form of visions/apparitions. The show will boil down to a conflict between Jacob and his nemesis, and since Aaron was to be raised by Claire because she is "good", Aaron will be the most important player on Jacob's "good" side.
  • Claire "Is not quite dead yet". For some reason yet to be explained, she had to survive the destruction of her house. Whenever she completes what she needs to do, she will die.
  • Not only was she guided to the cabin to break the circle of ash...she was then told by Jacob's nemesis to go to the temple and he will use something from the cabin to make it appear that Jacob sent Claire to the temple. Jacob's nemesis will tell Claire to wait for him with instructions and use her to get past the temple's defenses. It will turn out that Claire was in the temple since being seen in the cabin.

She now suffers from the sickness

  • Claire is to date the only 815 survivor to catch the sickness Danielle alluded to. Robert and Lacombe suffered from the sickness when they went under the temple where the monster is. Claire caught the sickness they have...that's why she was in the cabin. She's the thrall of the monster/Jacob's rival or possibly in the throws of madness.
    • What if Rousseau's so-called "sickness" is actually being possessed by the Smoke Monster/MIB? Robert and Lacombe could have been killed and possessed for all we know.

In the Future

  • She will be reunited with Thomas and Aaron and they will be a family. Thomas left Claire for the same reasons Desmond left Penny (for noble reasons, to be reunited in the end with her), and this will become apparent to all later on. This also explains why Thomas was, at first, ecstatic about having a child, and then suddenly wasn't.
  • In Kate's dream, when Claire tells her, "dont you dare bring him back Kate" she is not referring to Aaron. She is referring to Locke. Claire is dead, or at least in the same physical state as Christian, and being controlled or used in a similar manor. Claire says this know that if they bring Locke's body back to the island, Jacob's nemesis could inhabit it and become a threat.
  • Aaron will arrive on the island again and will be the driving force for the original locke to come back /only when all the original survivors are back in place will locke be the same, the reason locke was able to be taken over in the first place links to what mrs hawking said about if the new crash isnt the same as the same the result are "uknown"

Jacob's Cabin

  • Christian led Claire to Jacob's Cabin in order to keep her safe from the Kahana mercenaries. Christian did this on behalf of Jacob, since he (and the Island) would not let Claire die as she is the only one who can raise Aaron, stated by Malkin.
  • When Christian first met Claire he was much kinder to her than we ever see him being to Jack. This is why he lead Claire to safety.
  • Jacob's nemesis, posed as Christian, brought Claire to the cabin in order for her to break the circle of ash that was placed to keep him out. Claire followed because she thought that she was following her father Christian.

Desmond's Flash

  • Desmond's flash about Claire getting into the helicopter with her baby did not happen because Charlie died. Up to that point, everything Desmond saw in his flashes happened besides Charlie's death. As far as we know, only part of what Desmond said to Charlie happened (the yellow light went out, and Charlie died).
    • What Desmond saw in his flash will come to pass and Claire and Aaron will be rescued in Season 6. The events that Desmond saw just haven't happened yet.
    • Desmond lied to Charlie. He say himself getting into the helicopter/ being reunited with Penny, and told Charlie he had seen Claire get onto the helicopter so that Charlie would die an Desmond would get off the island.
    • Desmond actually saw Kate getting on the helicopter with Aaron, he thought it was Claire.
    • Claire is the loophole that Jacob's nemesis talked about. By making sure she wouldn't leave the island the other chain of events started. He did see Claire get in the helicopter. So far Desmond's flashes have all been extremely accurate in detail, with the exception that he changes details by saving Charlie, but in the end he couldn't prevent it.
  • Desmond's vision was indeed TRUE, but what he witnessed was, in fact, in an alternate timeline. This coincides with Desmond's unique ability of being "special" - meaning that his visions and rules regarding to time are directly related to the alternate timeline.

Pregnant on the Island

  • Claire's collapse in "White Rabbit" was the beginning of the "side-effects" of being pregnant on the island. This is how Ethan realised that the same thing that happened to women who conceived on the island was happening to Claire. Ethan then began injecting Claire with the serum after her collapse.
  • Ethan only took Claire to make sure nothing happened to her baby. They did not know that a baby could be born on the island at all. Claire had no side affects on the island because her baby was not conceived on the island. Women who conceived on the island had different problems (dying during the second trimester). Her fainting was a side effect of exhaustion and heat mixed with the fact that she is pregnant.
  • A left-field theory, about Claire being pregnant AFTER being seen in Jacob's cabin: Claire is Penelope's mother. If Claire wasn't dead when Locke found her in the cabin with Christian, it's possible Claire has been on the island jumping through time with the others, and finally settling in 1974. She then could have met Charles Widmore through Christian, and has spent three years with him. She would definitely qualify as an outsider, and may have started the complications with pregnant women: she would not have been born in 1977 - which could have side effects? Also, it's obvious Eloise and Charles had a major falling out over something: this would qualify.

This article uses material from the "Claire Littleton/Theories" article on the Lostpedia wiki at Wikia and is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike License.


Got something to say? Make a comment.
Your name
Your email address